Weighing Up the Benefits and Drawbacks of Contracting - CXC (2024)

Contracting is indisputably one of the fastest growing employment arrangements in Australia and around the world.The fact that so many people are choosing contracting over permanent employment and missing out on basic entitlements, such as paid holiday and sick leave, speaks volumes for the benefits that a contracting career entails.

This article explores the advantages and drawbacks a career as a contractor has to offer.

Greater remuneration

Considering most people work to earn a living and not purely for enjoyment sake, an increase in earning potential is viewed as the main benefit of contracting over permanent employment.

Typically, contractors are paid on an hourly or daily basis and are paid for every hour/day they work, unlike employees who are paid a salary. Contractors, doing the same job of a fulltime employee, typically find themselves raking in more money than their permanent counterparts.

Contractors are typically paid higher wages than their employee colleagues for a number of well-deserved reasons. The most obvious reason to support such a difference in wage is the fact that contractors surrender the right to entitlements that employees take for granted, such as sick leave and annual leave, plus employer contributions toward superannuation. It is up to the contractor themselves to make provisions for time of illness and times when they are not working, such as holidays and down time in between contracts.

Even if a permanent employee and a contractor were given the same payment for their work, it is very possible that the contractor will take home more than the employee. This is due to the fact that contractors have options in terms of how their remuneration is arranged and what business structure they operate under. For example, contractors who have their own company or paid via a trust can take advantage of tax deductions not available to employees. Contractors are also given the opportunity to salary package their income through their recruitment agency or contractor management company; benefits usually only reserved for people working in certain industries such as health.

Increased flexibility and experience

Although a major perk, money is not the only benefit gained by contractors. Another advantage of contracting is the freedom that is not available to permanent employees. Independent contractors can control where, when, and how they want to work. Employees need to go to their workplaces to be able to perform their work. Some contractors, on the other hand, have the ability to work remotely over the internet.

Additionally, many contracts can be relatively short – usually between 3 to 6 months. The constant exposure to new working environments and positions see contractors gain more skills than employees who are exposed to less variety in their work. This increased level of skill, which will be discussed further in this article, also justifies the hefty wage of a contractor.

Since contractors work on short-term contracts, they can afford to switch jobs periodically. The contract system opens more opportunities to expand employment prospects and experiences. Working on a new project or for another company offers continued changes and challenges that help contractors grow professionally. Aside from bringing a richer set of experience, this frequent change of work helps build contractors’ professional network and prevents contractors from getting bored and feeling constrained by a particular job or company. Contracting could be perfect for ambitious individuals who get itchy feet after staying at the same place and doing the same job for quite a long time. Moreover, independent contractors can do further work for another client as long as it does not affect their current job.

Downsides of contracting

There are many good reasons why one should consider becoming an independent contractor. However, there are also down sides to this kind of work that need careful consideration as well.

Depending on the duration of a contract, contract work can mean frequent job hunting. The frequent change of job and the constant re-establishment at another company can at times be frustrating for some. Also, a contractor is not always guaranteed immediate work opportunities. In fact, a contractor must be prepared to be unemployed during slow periods. Getting a new contract before an old one ends is not always the case. It is important that you plan ahead. Advising recruitment agencies that your contract is nearing its completion four weeks prior to end date is a good strategy for a contractor to get others to do their job hunting for them.

In contracting, there are times when it might be a necessity to relocate in order to get more work opportunities. Flexibility is a requirement when changing location, since it involves adjustments and necessary changes in lifestyle. Temporary relocation can also have its advantages, such as additional allowances like Living Away From Home Allowance and the opportunity to work interstate or even abroad.

Contract workers are prized for their skills and talents, so keeping their skills constantly updated is very essential if they want to remain competitive. This can consume time and demand substantial effort outside of normal working hours. It is assumed that client companies are less likely to offer further training to contractors since they are expected to possess the skills prior to the awarding of a contract. Although this assumption may ring some truth, many clients are using training and development as a tool to both attract and retain their valuable contractors.

As touched upon earlier, the lack of holiday and sick pay is another disadvantage of contracting. Unlike permanent employees, contractors are not paid when they take time off for holidays or because of sickness. Conversely, the flexibility that comes with contracting also refers to how much a contractor works. Contractors can take as much or as little time off as suits them. This can be either during or between contracts. On the other hand employees in Australia are typically limited to 20 days of annual leave, many of which are forced to take time off during seasonal periods or disallowed time off during festive periods due to the nature of their industry. On the contrary, clients are more charitable to contractors taking more holidays since the time off is not paid.

How a contractor management company can help

Managing paperwork, tax, and administration can prove to be a little bothersome and time consuming for some contractors who opt to set-up their own Company or operate as a Sole Trader. Those who would prefer to have their administration taken care of for them, can elect to contract via a contractor management company (CMC). CMC’s typically take care of all administration, such as invoicing clients and payroll; statutory obligations such as income tax and superannuation; plus insurance coverage like Workers Compensation, Public Liability and Professional Indemnity.

Contractor Management Companies can also assist with another issue facing many contractors; the difficulty of securing a home loan or other forms of credit without having a stable employer over an extended period of time. Multiple contracts through the one CMC, despite having various clients, can make applying for a home loan or credit easier, as all income and taxes will be paid by the one organisation, which can provide you with payslips and payment summaries.

Given all the pros and cons, deciding on becoming a contractor still remains a personal choice. Pursuing contract employment can be more financially lucrative dependent upon the individual’s circ*mstances and available opportunities. Contract employment is a good option to explore if you enjoy a variety of work and greater freedom, in terms of time and tasks. If viewed as a contributing aspect in one’s career path, contract work is definitely something to try!

As one of the world’s top suppliers ofcontingent worker management solutions,CXCis perfectly positioned to optimise all elements of yourcontingent workforce strategy. With operations in more than 50 countries across 5 continents, and with decades of experience, we can assist with every aspect of your program.

If you would like to find out more about how we can help with yourcontingent workforce solutionsplease contact ushere.

Share to:

ShareWeighing Up the Benefits and Drawbacks of Contracting - CXC (4)

Weighing Up the Benefits and Drawbacks of Contracting - CXC (2024)

FAQs

What are the advantages and disadvantages of contracting? ›

Why should you consider contracting?
  • Greater flexibility: When we ask our clients what they love about contracting, the improved flexibility on offer always comes up. ...
  • Increased earnings: ...
  • More opportunities for development: ...
  • More generally: ...
  • Responsibility: ...
  • Uncertainty: ...
  • Downtime between contracts:

What are the pros and cons of zero hour contracts? ›

For employees, this type of contract can offer flexibility and convenience but may also lead to job insecurity and unpredictable income. On the other hand, employers benefit from greater flexibility but must be careful to ensure that their workers are not taken advantage of by unfair working practices.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of subcontracting construction? ›

Choosing to be a subcontractor can mean a reliable source of work without seeking new clients or being employed by a company. However, it can come with some significant drawbacks — pay may be less reliable, taxes may be more complicated and you'll probably have less control over who you work with on a day-to-day basis.

What are the pros and cons of a contract position? ›

Many contract workers enjoy their flexible schedule because it allows them to work multiple jobs, care for children, or simply have greater control over their time. The downside is that they won't earn overtime or a supplemental pay rate if a specific project takes longer than expected as stated in the contract.

What are the disadvantages of contracting? ›

Cons of Contracting (positives for remaining a permanent employee)
  • Lack of Security. Looking for a job is almost a full-time job in itself! ...
  • Additional Headaches. ...
  • Lack of Training. ...
  • No Additional Benefits. ...
  • Higher Expectations to Perform. ...
  • Difficult to Return to Permanent Work.

What are the benefits of contracting? ›

A big benefit of contract work is the added flexibility it can bring. Contractors are often able to choose how many hours they do and when and where they do them. This offers them the chance for a greater work/life balance and a work schedule that suits them.

What are the negatives of zero-hour contracts? ›

Limited employment rights: Employees on zero-hour contracts may have limited access to employment rights, such as sick pay and holiday entitlement, depending on their specific contract terms. Difficulty obtaining credit: The uncertainty of income can make it challenging to secure loans or financial agreements.

Can you get fired on a zero-hour contract? ›

workers can be "dismissed" with little or no due process. Employers rarely dismiss a zero hours worker - they are simply told there is no work for the time being. This leaves workers unsure of their position, and whether they should or can claim benefits.

Do you get paid on a zero-hour contract? ›

How much you should get paid under a zero hours contract. People working under zero hours contracts are entitled to the National Minimum Wage and the National Living Wage for the hours they work. How much you get will depend on how old you are. If you are aged 23 or over, you get the National Living Wage.

What is the major disadvantage of subcontracting? ›

The downsides for subcontractors

Because they are considered self-employed, a subcontractor must manage their own business, even while working for someone else. That includes figuring out their own taxes, benefits, and insurance.

Which of the following is a drawback of subcontracting? ›

Subcontractors have to pay their own taxes and keep a track of expenses which in itself is quite a burden. Lot of time is wasted in calculating the taxes to be paid on a quarterly or yearly basis for all the work that has been done. The tax rates for self employment are higher than usual.

What is the major benefit in subcontracting process? ›

Outsourcing and subcontracting offer several benefits, including cost savings, access to specialized expertise, increased flexibility, and the ability to focus on core business functions.

What is better, contract or full-time? ›

Contractors often earn a higher hourly wage than full-time employees due to a lack of some benefits and shorter employment terms. Contractors also offer their specialized abilities to fill a need in an organization.

Is being a contractor worth it? ›

You might earn more as an independent contractor, and the tax benefits can include deducting your business expenses. The drawbacks to being an independent contractor include more responsibility. Independent contractors must fund 100% of their Medicare and Social Security taxes, health insurance, and retirement.

Is it better to be paid as a contractor or employee? ›

An employee may be able to obtain better benefits than an independent contractor. Employer subsidized health, life, disability and retirement benefits represent part of the “hidden paycheck” for employees that independent contractors don't always enjoy.

Why do people use zero-hour contracts? ›

Unlike a traditional contract of employment, a zero-hours contract offers no guarantee of work. Many employers use such contracts to cover situations where work fluctuates, and many individuals also find this to be a suitable working arrangement.

How ethical are zero-hour contracts? ›

The use of zero-hours contracts in particular can have negative implications for a business. While the use of zero-hour contracts is not necessarily unfair, their abuse by employers can cause reputational damage.

How does a zero-hour contract affect employment? ›

If you're on a zero-hours contract and legally classed as an employee, employers might offer redundancy. If you're on a zero-hours contract and legally classed as a worker, you are not entitled to redundancy. Employers could also stop your hours instead of offering redundancy.

What kinds of people were typically happy to work zero-hour contracts? ›

A survey undertaken by the Office for National Statistics states that people on zero hours' contracts are most likely to be young, part-time working women, or people in full-time education. 903,000 people surveyed throughout the UK were on a zero hours' contract.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Frankie Dare

Last Updated:

Views: 5726

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (53 voted)

Reviews: 84% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Frankie Dare

Birthday: 2000-01-27

Address: Suite 313 45115 Caridad Freeway, Port Barabaraville, MS 66713

Phone: +3769542039359

Job: Sales Manager

Hobby: Baton twirling, Stand-up comedy, Leather crafting, Rugby, tabletop games, Jigsaw puzzles, Air sports

Introduction: My name is Frankie Dare, I am a funny, beautiful, proud, fair, pleasant, cheerful, enthusiastic person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.