College Football Rankings Shakeup: Should Texas and Miami Leapfrog Notre Dame? It’s the question that’s dividing fans and analysts alike. As we dive into the second year of the expanded 12-team College Football Playoff, the rankings are more intriguing than ever. While the CFP committee’s rankings aren’t the final word due to the new seeding rules, they still spark endless debates—and let’s be honest, that’s half the fun. So, every week after the dust settles, I’ll be breaking down my top 10. But here’s where it gets controversial: Should Texas and Miami be ranked ahead of Notre Dame? Let’s dive in.
1. Ohio State (9-0)
Ohio State faced what were supposed to be their two toughest matchups this season—Texas and Penn State. Both teams, once considered national title contenders, have fallen short of expectations. While Texas is finally hitting its stride, Ohio State’s schedule lacks a truly marquee win. Yet, watch them play for just 10 minutes, and it’s clear: the Buckeyes are the team to beat. But the question remains—can anyone challenge them?
2. Indiana (10-0)
Indiana has dominated most of its opponents this season, but their win at Penn State on Saturday was anything but easy. The Hoosiers needed a last-minute drive, capped by a jaw-dropping touchdown pass from Fernando Mendoza to Omar Cooper. Cooper’s contortionist-like catch to secure the win might be the play of the year. Indiana remains undefeated, and their ability to grind out wins against tough opponents is just as impressive as their blowouts.
3. Texas A&M (9-0)
Texas A&M fans have lived in fear of their team being exposed as overrated, but week after week, the Aggies prove their doubters wrong. Their trip to Missouri on Saturday was expected to be a challenge, but they blew out the Tigers, 38-17. Led by star quarterback Marcel Reed, Texas A&M looks destined for the College Football Playoff. Could this finally be their year?
4. Alabama (8-1)
Alabama is back—and there’s no debate about it. Their season-opening loss to Florida State feels like a distant memory, clearly a fluke. The Crimson Tide’s defense dominated LSU on Saturday, proving they’re a force to be reckoned with. With eight straight wins, including victories over Georgia, Vanderbilt, Missouri, Tennessee, and now LSU, Alabama has earned its spot as the highest-ranked one-loss team. But with tough games against Oklahoma and Auburn ahead, can they keep it up?
5. Georgia (8-1)
Georgia has flirted with disaster in recent weeks, narrowly escaping losses. But their 41-21 win over Mississippi State on Saturday was a statement. While this Georgia team isn’t as dominant as past iterations, they keep winning under the leadership of the best coach in college football. Are we underestimating their ability to make another deep run?
6. Ole Miss (9-1)
Ole Miss had a glorified bye week against The Citadel, winning 49-0. Trinidad Chambliss threw for 333 yards and three touchdowns, but the real story is Lane Kiffin’s ability to keep his team focused amid coaching carousel rumors. With their only loss to Georgia, Ole Miss feels like a lock for the CFP, even if they don’t control their SEC destiny. But can they stay locked in with Florida and Mississippi State still on the schedule?
7. Texas Tech (9-1)
Texas Tech’s investment in its roster has paid off, thanks in part to a billionaire oil baron’s support. On Saturday, they dominated previously undefeated BYU without a fully healthy Behren Morton. The Red Raiders are the deepest, most talented team in the Big 12 and should be considered the conference favorite. But can they sustain this momentum?
8. Oregon (8-1)
Oregon faced a tough test at Iowa in terrible weather but pulled off a last-minute win with a game-winning field goal. Their only loss—a 10-point defeat to Indiana at home—has overshadowed their season. Yet, Indiana is one of the best teams in the country. Are we sleeping on the Ducks’ potential to make noise in the CFP?
9. Miami (7-2)
Miami’s ranking at No. 18 in the first CFP poll sparked debate, especially since they share the same record as Notre Dame (No. 10). Despite recent losses, the Hurricanes have a top-10 win and a victory over USF, a Group of 5 favorite. Their win against Syracuse on Saturday keeps them in the conversation, but do quality wins alone justify their ranking ahead of Notre Dame?
10. Texas (7-2)
Texas has had an inconsistent season, with Arch Manning’s slow start and a disappointing loss to Florida. However, four straight wins, including victories over Oklahoma and Vanderbilt, have turned heads. Their offensive line remains a concern, but their upcoming game at Georgia will reveal if they’re a legitimate threat. For now, Texas edges out Notre Dame in the rankings, but is that the right call?
And this is the part most people miss: The debate over Texas, Miami, and Notre Dame isn’t just about records—it’s about potential, quality wins, and momentum. So, I’ll leave you with this thought-provoking question: Which team deserves the higher ranking, and why? Let’s hear your take in the comments!
